Monday, April 27, 2026

The Hidden Light of Purim (Adapted from the Torah of Rav Yitzchok Hutner, zt”l, Pachad Yitzchok, Purim Maamar 34)

 The Hidden Light of Purim (Adapted from the Torah of Rav Yitzchok Hutner, zt”l, Pachad Yitzchok, Purim Maamar 34)

By Eliakim Willner

Eliakim Willner is author of an English volume of Pachad Yitzchok Maamorim, and of “Nesivos Olam – Nesiv HaTorah: An Appreciation of Torah Study”, a translation with commentary of a work by the Maharal of Prague, both published by Artscroll/Mesorah. A translation of the Maharal’s Nesiv HaAvodah awaits publication, along with many additional Maamorim.

 Long Term Benefits of a Short Term Solution

 “…and these days of Purim shall not be revoked from amidst the Jews, and their memory shall not cease from their descendants” (Esther 9:28). The Medrash explains that “even at a time when all the other holidays will be annulled, Purim will not be annulled, as the verse assures us: ‘…and their memory shall not cease from their descendants’”.

We can best understand this Medrash by way of a parable. Two individuals are ordered to recognize people in the darkness of night. One of them lit a candle and examined the faces of the people in its light in order to recognize them. The second individual had no candle, but since he was nonetheless obligated to recognize the people, he trained himself to recognize them by the differences in their voices.

Insofar as clarity and accuracy are concerned, the first individual had an advantage over the second since visual recognition is more certain than auditory recognition. On the other hand, the second individual had an advantage over the first in that he fine-tuned his sense of hearing with respect to distinguishing human voices. The individual who used a candle lacks the ability to accurately distinguish people using his sense of hearing. Thus, once morning dawns the first individual will extinguish his candle since it is useless in the light of day. The candle-driven recognition abilities that he strove to achieve at night are now redundant. As for the second individual, true, he too is now able to visually recognize people, but the fine-tuned auditory recognition abilities that he strove to achieve at night will remain with him forever.

The “Sixth Sense” of Purim 

In a leap year we read the Megilla in the second Adar month, in order to juxtapose the redemption that took place on Purim with the Egyptian redemption, which took place in Nissan. The deliberate juxtaposition of Purim with Pesach teaches us that there is a comparison to be made between the two redemptions. 

It is important for us to realize that just as the Egyptian redemption is marked by a divine declaration of Anochi, “I”, as in “I am Hashem, your G-d, Who took you out of the land of Egypt”, so too is the Purim redemption marked with its own Anochi declaration: “And I will surely hide, hastair astair…”. (The Gemara points to this phrase as an oblique reference to Purim: “Where is there a reference to Esther in the Torah? It is in the verse, ‘And I will surely hide, hastair, astair’” Devarim 31:18). The Anochi in both cases signals Hashem’s active involvement in both redemptions, albeit, as we will explain, in different ways

The significance of this fact is that there are two ways for the Jewish nation to recognize the Anochi, the “I”; the presence of Hashem as mastermind of events – either the Egyptian redemption way, or the Purim redemption way. Referring back to our earlier parable, the Jewish nation recognizing the Anochi in the Egyptian redemption way is comparable to the individual who recognizes others with the aid of a candle, a tool that provides light. The open miracles of the Egyptian redemption “illuminate” Hashem’s active involvement, as it were.

The Jewish nation recognizing the Anochi via a hidden and oblique redemption – the Purim way – on the other hand, is akin to the individual who recognizes people using a self-developed means of perception which enables him to bypass the sense of sight. There were no open miracles during the Purim redemption. Hashem’s involvement could only be discerned by “reading between the lines” of what appeared to be ordinary, natural events.

Let us expand our parable. When the day dawns brightly, and the sun rises in all its glory; that is to say – switching to the nimshal  – when, at the time of our final redemption, the light of Hashem’s glory will be orders of magnitude greater than the brightness of the sun, the earlier open miracles – the “tools” that the Jewish nation had to rely on previously in order to perceive the Anochi, the presence of Hashem as mastermind of events – will automatically become superfluous.

This is because the Anochi – the presence of Hashem as mastermind of all events – will permeate every aspect of existence after the final redemption, causing the miracles of the Egyptian exodus, in comparison, to pale into relative insignificance, just as the lesser light of a candle pales into insignificance in comparison to the light of the sun.

The miracles of the Egyptian exodus are akin to the candle of the parable. Just as a candle illuminates only its immediate vicinity, so do the Egyptian exodus miracles expose the hand of Hashem only in the events of the miracles themselves. The light of the much brighter sun is akin to the miracles of the final redemption, but in both cases our perception of Hashem’s active involvement does not extend beyond what the light illuminates; it does not extend to what appears to be “natural” everyday events. Both lights remain external tools for perceiving the involvement of Hashem.

All this is true about the holidays that are centered around the Egyptian redemption. It does not apply to the Purim redemption, in the context of which the Jewish nation taught itself to recognize Anochi – the presence of Hashem as mastermind of events – even during darkness; during hiddenness. This “sixth sense” of perception persists in the soul of the nation whether it is light or dark, just as, in the parable, the individual who taught himself to distinguish people by the sounds of their voices had no need for an illuminating tool at all in order to identify people. With our “Purim sense” we do not need to rely on the extraordinary light of the ultimate redemption to recognize Hashem as the mastermind of all events. No external “tools” in the form of open miracles are necessary.

That is why “even at a time when all the other holidays will be annulled, Purim will not be annulled, as the verse assures us: ‘…and their memory shall not cease from their descendants’”.

Supercharging the Mind with Ad D’lo’Yada 

In summary, there are two ways in which a person can be divinely enlightened. The first – the Egyptian redemption way –  can be expressed using the verse-phrase, “Hashem enlightens me” (Micha 7:8). The second first – the Purim redemption way –  can be expressed using the more expanded verse-phrase, “…although I will sit in darkness, Hashem enlightens me”.

Purim’s distinction is the enlightenment that “glows” even in the darkness. And just as the energy that guides a person even in the midst of darkness is more potent than ordinary light, so too are the intuitive insights that emerge in the below-the-level of consciousness glow of Purim especially cherished.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment